The basic #44 unit is the same and will fit. That being said, the GPM of the pump is usually quite a bit higher on the D4 pump, (different cartridge that is not directly interchangeable with a D2 cartridge) the input shaft is different, mounting brackets different, control levers different. So yes it can be done, if you can find or make the parts you need ,but you would be better off if you can find one from a D2.