maybe this will help: http://www.chriscomachinery.com/PullGraders.htm
Std Blade Grader S-1001 to S-4950 1912-1925
Reverse Blade Grader S-501 to S-1000 1908-1912
According to your list, I either mistook a 3 for a 5, or is it possible that Cat sold some machines under the Russel brand the first year after takeover. I will take some soapstone and double check the serial number.
I do know that Cat purchased Russell in 1928 and i have seen graders with both the russell tag and caterpillar tag.