I was tought to replace all four and have always done so. If one nozzle is stronger than the other three then one cylinder will operate differently than the others. You might get by replacing the damaged nozzle with a used nozzle but you'd have to test the three old nozzles and the used replacement nozzle to insure they were comperable. CAT sells nozzles for $50 each. I was tought not to buy aftermarket and after a demonstration on a test pump I learned why. Waste the $200 and buy CAT if you are not able or do not want to try a used replacement. Make sure to coat the injector with antisieze before install. I am partial to the copper variety CAT sells; it works well in the nastiest places.