ACMOC
Login
ACMOC
Advice for my D2 3J pony please

Advice for my D2 3J pony please

Showing 1 to 10 of 28 results
1
neil
Topic Author
Offline
Moderator
Admin
Super Admin
Send a private message to neil
Posts: 7,025
Thank you received: 24
I'm at the stage of getting the freeze cracks on my D2 3J pony brazed up and I'm looking ahead to bearings and seals. All these questions relate to the pony:

- I can visibly see the crank move up and down in the main bearings so I want to replace them - is Cat the best source for those two, and, what is the best approach to getting the end float "just right". I'm not sure if that's even adjustable?
- is Cat the best source for a new flywheel nut and lock washer? Mine's had the cold chisel removal method applied...
- Olson quotes $240 for an overhaul gasket set; good deal?
- what were the recommended spark plugs? I seem to recall Autolite 386?
- what can I clean out the coolant passages with (a la citric) but without then having to do something about the machined surfaces? I'd like to get all the scale/rust out of the pony (and the main for that matter later on when I tackle that part)


Last, after brazing, how much can I skim the heads/block to get it good enough? I'd rather not skim any if I can get away with it. Perhaps I should just put the heads back on with new gaskets and "see" what it's like? Thanks in advance.

Cheers,
Neil.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Sun, Mar 27, 2011 1:14 AM
ccjersey
Offline
Send a private message to ccjersey
Posts: 4,422
Thank you received: 0
I would measure up your crankshaft and see if you can use standard bearings or if it's been turned undersize etc. CAT is going to be the easiest source, but possibly could find them somewhere else???? If it's already undersize and clearances are too great to just replace the bearings, I know someone here has posted about shrinking a sleeve onto the crankshaft and turning back to standard. I would say the economics of that would depend a lot on whether the rod bearing throws are regrindable etc. There's bound to be some good used crankshafts out there in blocks that have been damaged by water getting inside the cylinders etc.

Used would likely be the best source for a nut and washer. Or just take a hammer and file to it! Peen the smushed metal back down and dress it up with the file etc.

You can make a lot of gaskets for $240! All of them should be available from CAT dealer if you want to price them. There wouldn't be so many that you can't just total them up and compare pretty easily. Head gaskets would be the only thing that's not possible to make, and possibly can be reused with some sealer applied. I have heard lots of folks use coppr-kote spray or a coating of aluminum paint, but I would assume a coating of brush-on gasket maker like permatex might work just as well and help on the pitting The only place I would say would demand a skim would be the fire ring area around the cylinders. Almost anything on the rest of the surface could be handled with a sealer.

Easiest thing to do with the block while you have it off and stripped down is to take it and have it hot tanked at a shop. If you want to do it yourself, I would say wash it with Tide or some other good detergent to remove any grease before you put it in a citric acid bath. After the bath, you should be able to poke through all the coolant passages with a stiff wire and blow through with air or water spray. Don't forget the heads and top cover when you do it! I don't think the citric acid will hurt the sealing surfaces at all. You need a little bit of texture on that kind of thing to keep the gaskets from creeping as you tighten things down.

The end play on the crankshaft is not adjustable except by shims/gasket thickness under the cover behind the flywheel which carries the "rear" main and the crankshaft seal. The spec I have on the larger pony motor will likely do for yours 0.010-0.016" (max 0.030") The usuall problem with excessive end clearance is when the main bearing opposite the flywheel looses it's hollow retaining dowel and moves in the bore of the crankcase casting. When you install the dowel, I would retain it with locktite or punch it so it is positively retained in the block. Also do not strike the flywheel and drive the crankshaft axially when installing or removing the flywheel
D2-5J's, D6-9U's, D318 and D333 power units, 12E-99E grader, 922B & 944A wheel loaders, D330C generator set, DW20 water tanker and a bunch of Jersey cows to take care of in my spare time😄
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Sun, Mar 27, 2011 3:05 AM
Mike Meyer
Offline
Member
Send a private message to Mike Meyer
Posts: 3,332
Thank you received: 5
Reply to ccjersey:
I would measure up your crankshaft and see if you can use standard bearings or if it's been turned undersize etc. CAT is going to be the easiest source, but possibly could find them somewhere else???? If it's already undersize and clearances are too great to just replace the bearings, I know someone here has posted about shrinking a sleeve onto the crankshaft and turning back to standard. I would say the economics of that would depend a lot on whether the rod bearing throws are regrindable etc. There's bound to be some good used crankshafts out there in blocks that have been damaged by water getting inside the cylinders etc.

Used would likely be the best source for a nut and washer. Or just take a hammer and file to it! Peen the smushed metal back down and dress it up with the file etc.

You can make a lot of gaskets for $240! All of them should be available from CAT dealer if you want to price them. There wouldn't be so many that you can't just total them up and compare pretty easily. Head gaskets would be the only thing that's not possible to make, and possibly can be reused with some sealer applied. I have heard lots of folks use coppr-kote spray or a coating of aluminum paint, but I would assume a coating of brush-on gasket maker like permatex might work just as well and help on the pitting The only place I would say would demand a skim would be the fire ring area around the cylinders. Almost anything on the rest of the surface could be handled with a sealer.

Easiest thing to do with the block while you have it off and stripped down is to take it and have it hot tanked at a shop. If you want to do it yourself, I would say wash it with Tide or some other good detergent to remove any grease before you put it in a citric acid bath. After the bath, you should be able to poke through all the coolant passages with a stiff wire and blow through with air or water spray. Don't forget the heads and top cover when you do it! I don't think the citric acid will hurt the sealing surfaces at all. You need a little bit of texture on that kind of thing to keep the gaskets from creeping as you tighten things down.

The end play on the crankshaft is not adjustable except by shims/gasket thickness under the cover behind the flywheel which carries the "rear" main and the crankshaft seal. The spec I have on the larger pony motor will likely do for yours 0.010-0.016" (max 0.030") The usuall problem with excessive end clearance is when the main bearing opposite the flywheel looses it's hollow retaining dowel and moves in the bore of the crankcase casting. When you install the dowel, I would retain it with locktite or punch it so it is positively retained in the block. Also do not strike the flywheel and drive the crankshaft axially when installing or removing the flywheel
Base gasket is $7, manifold gasket is $15, head gaskets are $15 each, the smaller gaskets are $2 or $3. I've bought several sets of gaskets individually from Florin Tractor parts, all good quality. I've used Permatex #3 to reseal the head gaskets successfully too.

Those heads are devils to get clean, I found a pressure washer and a length of wire gently probing around works well, you will find if you let the heads dry out over time it will allow more loose crud to become dislodged. I cleaned my heads 5 or 6 times over 3 weeks and kept getting small bits of rust crud out.

I also did a long term soak in Citric Acid last winter that went pear shaped, I left the heads in a small bath sitting outside for 2 weeks thinking it would be A1, but found by week 3 I had etched the machined faces on the heads slightly and needed to machine them. It was frosty weather at the time. I love Citric Acid, it is excellent, but just be aware it can etch machined steel faces under certain conditions.

I used about a cup of acid powder in 5 or 6 gallons of water that time, so it was a pretty strong solution, normally I use about 4 or 5 cups of powder in 100 gallons of water. I have a large plastic stock trough that I can place larger items into, like the rolled up tracks off my D2 that were rusted badly, it worked brilliantly.

Be aware also that water passage below the pilot motor is fairly small and I've noticed on my old Cats where I've removed pilot motors that it can be easily blocked with the typical sludge and rusty crud that gets dislodged during a rebuild. Use flush water generously in all directions, you will be amazed how each time you do it more little bits of crud come out.

Cat Dealers are the best place to buy nuts and bolts, they are the right product at the best price, cheaper than most any other sources I've found. Those gaskets are available from Cat Dealers too, just a lot more expensive.
Good luck
Mike
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Sun, Mar 27, 2011 4:30 AM
zootownjeepguy
Offline
Send a private message to zootownjeepguy
Posts: 759
Thank you received: 0
Reply to ccjersey:
I would measure up your crankshaft and see if you can use standard bearings or if it's been turned undersize etc. CAT is going to be the easiest source, but possibly could find them somewhere else???? If it's already undersize and clearances are too great to just replace the bearings, I know someone here has posted about shrinking a sleeve onto the crankshaft and turning back to standard. I would say the economics of that would depend a lot on whether the rod bearing throws are regrindable etc. There's bound to be some good used crankshafts out there in blocks that have been damaged by water getting inside the cylinders etc.

Used would likely be the best source for a nut and washer. Or just take a hammer and file to it! Peen the smushed metal back down and dress it up with the file etc.

You can make a lot of gaskets for $240! All of them should be available from CAT dealer if you want to price them. There wouldn't be so many that you can't just total them up and compare pretty easily. Head gaskets would be the only thing that's not possible to make, and possibly can be reused with some sealer applied. I have heard lots of folks use coppr-kote spray or a coating of aluminum paint, but I would assume a coating of brush-on gasket maker like permatex might work just as well and help on the pitting The only place I would say would demand a skim would be the fire ring area around the cylinders. Almost anything on the rest of the surface could be handled with a sealer.

Easiest thing to do with the block while you have it off and stripped down is to take it and have it hot tanked at a shop. If you want to do it yourself, I would say wash it with Tide or some other good detergent to remove any grease before you put it in a citric acid bath. After the bath, you should be able to poke through all the coolant passages with a stiff wire and blow through with air or water spray. Don't forget the heads and top cover when you do it! I don't think the citric acid will hurt the sealing surfaces at all. You need a little bit of texture on that kind of thing to keep the gaskets from creeping as you tighten things down.

The end play on the crankshaft is not adjustable except by shims/gasket thickness under the cover behind the flywheel which carries the "rear" main and the crankshaft seal. The spec I have on the larger pony motor will likely do for yours 0.010-0.016" (max 0.030") The usuall problem with excessive end clearance is when the main bearing opposite the flywheel looses it's hollow retaining dowel and moves in the bore of the crankcase casting. When you install the dowel, I would retain it with locktite or punch it so it is positively retained in the block. Also do not strike the flywheel and drive the crankshaft axially when installing or removing the flywheel
Hi Neil,

Olson gaskets are a bit pricey in my opinion. They wanted nearly $2200 for a complete pony set and Diesel upper & lower sets last time I checked.

New pony head gaskets are only $11.78 each from Cat (I just bought a set). There is a pair of pony head gaskets on Fee-Bay right now in Canada for only $50, plus shipping, plus duty fees to get them back in the USA, ...not a good deal from where I'm sitting. I would think that you could get all of the pony gaskets direct from Cat for well under $100. The rear main bearing (behind the flywheel) was quoted to me for about $135-ish from Cat just a few weeks ago.

Recommended spark plugs are Champion D-16, but most everyone on this BB would recommend NOT using Champion's. Cross the Champion number over to Ac, Autolite or anything but Champion. Use a plug with a black-oxide finished base, not cadmium plated.
Rich Salvaggio
D2 5U9917
'46 Willys CJ2A Farm Jeep, '39 Buick sedan, '49 International KB-7, '37 Allis Chalmers WC, Cushman Scooter(s)
Antique garden tractors & outboard motors
Other rusty old junk comes & goes without warning.

The 2 most useful tools to have in your shop are a Crystal Ball and a Magic Wand
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Sun, Mar 27, 2011 4:34 AM
neil
Topic Author
Offline
Moderator
Admin
Super Admin
Send a private message to neil
Posts: 7,025
Thank you received: 24
Reply to zootownjeepguy:
Hi Neil,

Olson gaskets are a bit pricey in my opinion. They wanted nearly $2200 for a complete pony set and Diesel upper & lower sets last time I checked.

New pony head gaskets are only $11.78 each from Cat (I just bought a set). There is a pair of pony head gaskets on Fee-Bay right now in Canada for only $50, plus shipping, plus duty fees to get them back in the USA, ...not a good deal from where I'm sitting. I would think that you could get all of the pony gaskets direct from Cat for well under $100. The rear main bearing (behind the flywheel) was quoted to me for about $135-ish from Cat just a few weeks ago.

Recommended spark plugs are Champion D-16, but most everyone on this BB would recommend NOT using Champion's. Cross the Champion number over to Ac, Autolite or anything but Champion. Use a plug with a black-oxide finished base, not cadmium plated.
Awesome - thanks you guys. I'll call Dana at Florin and see if he wants to send me the set. I haven't been into the local Cat dealer so I don't know that I want to spend time "educating" the new guy behind the counter (although I will go get those extra studs and whatnot that I need. By the way, I tried the old left-hand drill trick to get out a broken-flush stud and it worked very well - not an ounce of damage to the threaded hole in the block - very happy about that!
I noticed that only the top (read: accessible) big end nut was pinned so I bought some spares to do the bottom as well. It's not easy getting a pair of mitts in there but I'd rather take the extra time and know that it's secure.
Mike - I see that the camshaft runs directly in the bores (doesn't seem to be any bearing there. I'd be a bit nervous about dunking that into the citric. Perhaps I can glue some pipes onto the block and run the citric only in the coolant passages rather than dunking the whole block?
Cheers,
Neil.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Sun, Mar 27, 2011 8:15 AM
Mike Meyer
Offline
Member
Send a private message to Mike Meyer
Posts: 3,332
Thank you received: 5
Reply to neil:
Awesome - thanks you guys. I'll call Dana at Florin and see if he wants to send me the set. I haven't been into the local Cat dealer so I don't know that I want to spend time "educating" the new guy behind the counter (although I will go get those extra studs and whatnot that I need. By the way, I tried the old left-hand drill trick to get out a broken-flush stud and it worked very well - not an ounce of damage to the threaded hole in the block - very happy about that!
I noticed that only the top (read: accessible) big end nut was pinned so I bought some spares to do the bottom as well. It's not easy getting a pair of mitts in there but I'd rather take the extra time and know that it's secure.
Mike - I see that the camshaft runs directly in the bores (doesn't seem to be any bearing there. I'd be a bit nervous about dunking that into the citric. Perhaps I can glue some pipes onto the block and run the citric only in the coolant passages rather than dunking the whole block?
Cheers,
Neil.
I just did the heads in Citric Acid, not the block, use a long piece of wire and your pressure washer on the block, those cooling passages are a good size, it's just within the heads I noticed they are much smaller with bends and curves to jag any trash that gets dislodged from the main motor or radiator.

Re Florin, I find I get faster service from Judy, I think Dana must be flat out on bigger customers and my little orders got overlooked till I lucked onto Judy. If you need part numbers sing out.
Good luck
Mike
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Sun, Mar 27, 2011 10:08 AM
neil
Topic Author
Offline
Moderator
Admin
Super Admin
Send a private message to neil
Posts: 7,025
Thank you received: 24
Reply to Mike Meyer:
I just did the heads in Citric Acid, not the block, use a long piece of wire and your pressure washer on the block, those cooling passages are a good size, it's just within the heads I noticed they are much smaller with bends and curves to jag any trash that gets dislodged from the main motor or radiator.

Re Florin, I find I get faster service from Judy, I think Dana must be flat out on bigger customers and my little orders got overlooked till I lucked onto Judy. If you need part numbers sing out.
Good luck
Mike
Mike,
did you remove that frost plug on the underside of the block? I assume that's a coolant passage it's enclosing? I did notice that the little round coolant hole on the bottom of the head/block on one cylinder was completely blocked.
I got the crank out today and noticed these things:
- front main (with 16tooth gear) was considerably looser than the rear (flywheel) and that the dowel was flogged in the hole. I could fit a 005 feeler gauge part way in, which I think is too much. I can wobble the bearing on the journal.
- both mains have what looks like a "burnt oil" patch on them. I think it's actually rust

I'm going to see who can hot-tank it in town but I need someone to tell me that that's not going to jigger the camshaft bores, which don't seem to have bearings?

Cheers,
Neil.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Mon, Mar 28, 2011 6:35 AM
ccjersey
Offline
Send a private message to ccjersey
Posts: 4,422
Thank you received: 0
hot tanking would probably damage bearings, but should have no effect on the cast iron itself. The shop should be able to confirm this. I know there's different chemicals used.
D2-5J's, D6-9U's, D318 and D333 power units, 12E-99E grader, 922B & 944A wheel loaders, D330C generator set, DW20 water tanker and a bunch of Jersey cows to take care of in my spare time😄
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Mon, Mar 28, 2011 10:44 AM
neil
Topic Author
Offline
Moderator
Admin
Super Admin
Send a private message to neil
Posts: 7,025
Thank you received: 24
Reply to ccjersey:
hot tanking would probably damage bearings, but should have no effect on the cast iron itself. The shop should be able to confirm this. I know there's different chemicals used.
I checked in with a local shop today and he said that his hot tank solution was pretty weak. I've pulled everything but some of the head studs and the three copper oil drain pipes from it so after I get the freeze cracks brazed up I'll get them to clean it. I'll take the crank in tomorrow and get him to mic it to see whether I need to go standard or undersize bearings. I'm still surprised that the camshaft doesn't run in bearings.

Any word on whether I should pull that freeze plug on the underside of the block?
Cheers,
Neil.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Tue, Mar 29, 2011 8:35 AM
Mike Meyer
Offline
Member
Send a private message to Mike Meyer
Posts: 3,332
Thank you received: 5
Reply to neil:
I checked in with a local shop today and he said that his hot tank solution was pretty weak. I've pulled everything but some of the head studs and the three copper oil drain pipes from it so after I get the freeze cracks brazed up I'll get them to clean it. I'll take the crank in tomorrow and get him to mic it to see whether I need to go standard or undersize bearings. I'm still surprised that the camshaft doesn't run in bearings.

Any word on whether I should pull that freeze plug on the underside of the block?
Cheers,
Neil.
Hi Neil, I have everything open on my main motor, thermostat is out so I can back flush better, drain plug, water temperature sender and radiator is off so I can get some good volume flowing.

The pilot is on the main motor, however the heads were off. Those little water ports on those heads get blocked by the smallest trash, take your time there with some softish wire and the pressure washer.
regards
Mike
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Tue, Mar 29, 2011 8:44 AM
Mike Meyer
Offline
Member
Send a private message to Mike Meyer
Posts: 3,332
Thank you received: 5
Reply to Mike Meyer:
Hi Neil, I have everything open on my main motor, thermostat is out so I can back flush better, drain plug, water temperature sender and radiator is off so I can get some good volume flowing.

The pilot is on the main motor, however the heads were off. Those little water ports on those heads get blocked by the smallest trash, take your time there with some softish wire and the pressure washer.
regards
Mike
Hi Neil, From what I read here, those little dowels in that "front" crankshaft bearing are notorious for coming loose, or even right out, and I believe one of their key roles is to catch, and then guide oil down to that bearing.

Most other folks here are far more knowledgable than me, but I seem to recall a new dowel hole being drilled in that bearing carrier as a common repair, possibly with the use of some Loctite?

If your radiator is off, think about pulling the thermostat Neil just to check it's performance and to aid good flushing. I used a home made slide hammer to pop the thermostats locking ring off which I intend to re use, however my thermostat on my 4U was frozen open, so I'm glad I went the extra yard. I noticed quite a bit of flakey, rusty trash had accumulated directly below the thermostat on my tractor and it was easily removed with thermostat out.
regards
Mike
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Tue, Mar 29, 2011 8:59 AM
Showing 1 to 10 of 28 results
1
YouTube Video Placeholder

Follow Us on Social Media

Our channel highlights machines from the earliest Holt and Best track-type tractors, equipment from the start of Caterpillar in 1925, up to units built in the mid-1960s.

Upcoming Events

The Century of Caterpillar

| Elkader, 203 Johnson St, Elkader, IA 52043, USA

Clarendon Classic

Chapter Twenty Nine

| Hawkesbury Showground, Racecourse Rd, Clarendin, NSW, Australia

Chapter 18 100 Years of Caterpillar - Kingaroy

Chapter Eighteen

| Geoff Ralph Drive, Taabinga, 4610, Kingaroy, Qld.

Yorke Peninsula Field Days

Chapter Thirty

| 3429 Copper Coast Highway Paskeville, SA 5572
View Calendar
ACMOC

Antique Caterpillar
Machinery Owners Club

1115 Madison St NE # 1117
Salem, OR 97301

[email protected]

Terms & Privacy
Website developed by AdCo

Testimonials

"I became a member recently because the wealth of knowledge here is priceless." 
-Chris R

Join Today!