ACMOC
Login
ACMOC
225 is almost ready but need strategy to dig large pond.

225 is almost ready but need strategy to dig large pond.

Showing 1 to 10 of 23 results
1
bobby1
Topic Author
Offline
Send a private message to bobby1
Posts: 288
Thank you received: 0
Biggest dilemma I will likely have to work most of this solo. I have done some in depth calcs and it looks like possibly a scraper is a better choice for the major part of the dig, and follow with shaping with the 225. Let me break this down for thought.

2 ponds, each approx .75 acre area
Total soil moved will be about 25-30k yds compacted
travel distance is no more than 800ft from dig site to drop site.
no concerns with settling and shape as it will all be worked with a dozer later.

Method 1 is the 1978 225 with about a 1.2yd bucket filling a tandem dump truck. Really need 2 trucks running to be efficient

Method 2 225 spoiling a pile and find a very large loader to help but still needs 2 people

Method 3 find/buy a motor scraper to dig the majority since they are a one man band and final shape and haul with 225 and dump truck

Method 4 find a pull tractor and pull pan but I find that these, though pretty bullet proof, use up a lot of power because they do not paddle the soil in the pan.

I should further add that soil is sandy loam with more of a clay loam after 5ft. Probably will not go much past 10ft deep. No major rock to deal with.


I will further mention that time, machinery cost, and fuel is all being considered here. Certainly will not be free but I also cannot near afford to run down to me nearest CAT dealer and rent up a bunch of machines.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 5:26 AM
7upuller
Offline
Deceased
Send a private message to 7upuller
Posts: 3,737
Thank you received: 0
Method #5,

Get toghether with a few local cat collector's, put on a few Playday's and let people move dirt for free👍

Where are you located. Our local chapter is always looking for scraper dirt.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 7:16 AM
Deas Plant.
Offline
Member
Send a private message to Deas Plant.
Location: Currently - DowNunda.
Posts: 6,660
Thank you received: 18
Reply to 7upuller:
Method #5,

Get toghether with a few local cat collector's, put on a few Playday's and let people move dirt for free👍

Where are you located. Our local chapter is always looking for scraper dirt.
Hi, Fastline.
If you are anywhere near Glen, just hand the whole issue over to him and the Chapter 5 boys and they will do it for you. You can then join in the fun, meet new friends, maybe learn new skills and have a ball doing it all.

There is an art to dam-sinking and building ponds and almost every dam or pond that I have ever had to repair was put in by an excavator. It seems that many excavator operators, when faced with building any sort of water storage, just want to dig a hole. No thought about sealing it, claying up the walls or putting in a clay core to stop leakage.

It sounds as if you have some good materials with which to build your ponds - so long as it is done properly.

If you don't live near to Glen, then I'd suggest either #3 or #4 of your options above. The BIG plus of a scraper or a tractor-pan combo is that they place and level AND compact the material all in the one process. On top of this, it sounds like you will need to excavate down to the clay-ier material in your wall areas to get a base to start building up from with the clay material that will seal and hold water in. This 'keying in' could be done with your excavator on your own by digging a trench along where you want the upstream face of the wall to be and side-casting the excavated material into the rest of the wall area. This trench should ideally be wide enough to be able get some reasonable compaction on the clay core material that you place in there when you start claying up the wall.

You can begin moving the top 5 feet of loamy material and placing that in the main part of the wall until you expose the clay material so that you can begin back-filling your core tranch.

If you don't live near Glen, you might like to take his suggestion and contact the ACMOC chapter in your area to see if they would like to do a few play days. Failing an ACMOC chapter in your area, as Glen said, contact a few 'yellow rustaholics' and see if they would like to join in and help out.

Hope this helps.

Hi, Glen,
You've already got that itch to get dust and diesel fumes up your nose again, haven't you? In fact, did you even lose it while they had you on the operating table?

Take it easy and get well soon.

You have a wonderful day. Best wishes. Deas Plant.

Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 8:54 AM
bobby1
Topic Author
Offline
Send a private message to bobby1
Posts: 288
Thank you received: 0
Reply to Deas Plant.:
Hi, Fastline.
If you are anywhere near Glen, just hand the whole issue over to him and the Chapter 5 boys and they will do it for you. You can then join in the fun, meet new friends, maybe learn new skills and have a ball doing it all.

There is an art to dam-sinking and building ponds and almost every dam or pond that I have ever had to repair was put in by an excavator. It seems that many excavator operators, when faced with building any sort of water storage, just want to dig a hole. No thought about sealing it, claying up the walls or putting in a clay core to stop leakage.

It sounds as if you have some good materials with which to build your ponds - so long as it is done properly.

If you don't live near to Glen, then I'd suggest either #3 or #4 of your options above. The BIG plus of a scraper or a tractor-pan combo is that they place and level AND compact the material all in the one process. On top of this, it sounds like you will need to excavate down to the clay-ier material in your wall areas to get a base to start building up from with the clay material that will seal and hold water in. This 'keying in' could be done with your excavator on your own by digging a trench along where you want the upstream face of the wall to be and side-casting the excavated material into the rest of the wall area. This trench should ideally be wide enough to be able get some reasonable compaction on the clay core material that you place in there when you start claying up the wall.

You can begin moving the top 5 feet of loamy material and placing that in the main part of the wall until you expose the clay material so that you can begin back-filling your core tranch.

If you don't live near Glen, you might like to take his suggestion and contact the ACMOC chapter in your area to see if they would like to do a few play days. Failing an ACMOC chapter in your area, as Glen said, contact a few 'yellow rustaholics' and see if they would like to join in and help out.

Hope this helps.

Hi, Glen,
You've already got that itch to get dust and diesel fumes up your nose again, haven't you? In fact, did you even lose it while they had you on the operating table?

Take it easy and get well soon.
WOW, that would be really fun to move dirt and enjoy the process!! This is the place I will die so doing it right and having fun are part of the deal.

I am in S central KS unfortunately. I don't know a sole around here that would want to move dirt for fun... Would be neat to show off the old 225 or at least my resurrection of it. Far from a cream puff but was headed to the scrap yard when I grabbed it up. Engine and pumps are solid and with a little help here, I am just shocked that the old girl may get a nice retirement on the farm.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 9:54 AM
7upuller
Offline
Deceased
Send a private message to 7upuller
Posts: 3,737
Thank you received: 0
Reply to bobby1:
WOW, that would be really fun to move dirt and enjoy the process!! This is the place I will die so doing it right and having fun are part of the deal.

I am in S central KS unfortunately. I don't know a sole around here that would want to move dirt for fun... Would be neat to show off the old 225 or at least my resurrection of it. Far from a cream puff but was headed to the scrap yard when I grabbed it up. Engine and pumps are solid and with a little help here, I am just shocked that the old girl may get a nice retirement on the farm.
Need to find a 14-A D8 with a pull scraper. Fuel will run about 33-50 cents a cyd(rough numbers, too many variables) You can work by yourself. Have to start early in season so there is moisture in the dirt, eliminates a water tuck. A pto driven canon also works good for moisture, if you have a water source close by.

The excavator will move the dirt, but needs assistance with haul vehicles, and such.

Look up your local chapter leader of ACMOC. Go to a meeting and tell them you want to host a play day, see what the response is.-glen
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 10:29 AM
bobby1
Topic Author
Offline
Send a private message to bobby1
Posts: 288
Thank you received: 0
Reply to 7upuller:
Need to find a 14-A D8 with a pull scraper. Fuel will run about 33-50 cents a cyd(rough numbers, too many variables) You can work by yourself. Have to start early in season so there is moisture in the dirt, eliminates a water tuck. A pto driven canon also works good for moisture, if you have a water source close by.

The excavator will move the dirt, but needs assistance with haul vehicles, and such.

Look up your local chapter leader of ACMOC. Go to a meeting and tell them you want to host a play day, see what the response is.-glen
It looks like the closest chapter leader is about 3.5hrs away. I would need to schedule some reason to be up there I guess. Is there any way to search members in my area by chance?

Also, you might be able to answer a question regarding scrapers. I have excavation experience but NONE on a scraper. It seems the simplest scrapers are just pull pans either motorized or pull type but require significantly more power to load. The paddle scrapers like the 613 seem to load better on their own if in the right soil conditions.

I stumbled on a Terex locally. I think it is a ts14B which is a twin engine but not a paddle and they look to operate like turds. I am also not much a Terex fan growing up around CAT and Deere.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 10:39 AM
7upuller
Offline
Deceased
Send a private message to 7upuller
Posts: 3,737
Thank you received: 0
Reply to bobby1:
It looks like the closest chapter leader is about 3.5hrs away. I would need to schedule some reason to be up there I guess. Is there any way to search members in my area by chance?

Also, you might be able to answer a question regarding scrapers. I have excavation experience but NONE on a scraper. It seems the simplest scrapers are just pull pans either motorized or pull type but require significantly more power to load. The paddle scrapers like the 613 seem to load better on their own if in the right soil conditions.

I stumbled on a Terex locally. I think it is a ts14B which is a twin engine but not a paddle and they look to operate like turds. I am also not much a Terex fan growing up around CAT and Deere.
Cat Scrapers 621 is a 20 cyd+/- conventional open bowl scraper. Needs to be loaded by usaully a D-8.
A 623 is somewhat the same size and machine, but a paddlewheel that can load it self. It still requires assistance by a blade or dozer.
A 627 is somewhat the same size as 621 but open boweled, front and rear engine machine. Can be loaded with a dozer, or by another 627 push pull. Again a dozer is still in the cut helping.

A Ts 14 is a twin engine machine it can load some what by itself maybe to 50% of a load(all depends on grade and material), but usualy can't work by it self.

Find a Cat crawler, D-6, D-7, D-8, or even a D-9. Find a pull scraper propelly sized and go for it. In your situation, with Deas's $.02 and my opinion, the pull scraper method is your cheapest way to go, if you don't want to spend $ on labor helping you.

With your 225, If you moved 750 cyd a day (not being an expert) and rented two dumps, let's say $75 an hour or $1200 a day for 40 days to move 30,000 cyd, it's $48,000 for the trucks, plus fuel for the 225 $8000, your in $56,000

Spend $15,000 on a 14-A and scraper (move 600 cyd day) $10,000 on fuel, your in it $25,000, then sell the Cat and scraper. Of course I did not figure your time in either scenario.-glen
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 11:12 AM
Deas Plant.
Offline
Member
Send a private message to Deas Plant.
Location: Currently - DowNunda.
Posts: 6,660
Thank you received: 18
Reply to bobby1:
It looks like the closest chapter leader is about 3.5hrs away. I would need to schedule some reason to be up there I guess. Is there any way to search members in my area by chance?

Also, you might be able to answer a question regarding scrapers. I have excavation experience but NONE on a scraper. It seems the simplest scrapers are just pull pans either motorized or pull type but require significantly more power to load. The paddle scrapers like the 613 seem to load better on their own if in the right soil conditions.

I stumbled on a Terex locally. I think it is a ts14B which is a twin engine but not a paddle and they look to operate like turds. I am also not much a Terex fan growing up around CAT and Deere.
Hi, Fastline.
Chapter One covers Kansas-Missouri. President is Fred Stitt - cell 816 289 2822 or e-mail: [email protected] He ought to be able to put you on to members in Kansas near you.

Happy hunting.

Glen's thumbnail calculations above will give you some idea of what you can expect the project to cost you and some of the options. A real good man with an elevator scraper could probably do most of it on his own. I know i could. How-wevver, when you start turning the inexperienced loose on building walls and banks, you start to run into safety issues like falling over the edge, etc.. Having a dozer or a blade around can help to reduce these risks.

Something of the same risks apply when using a crawler and drawn pan but the crawler is a bit more sure-footed than a wheeled scraper and doesn't travel as fast so you get into trouble a little slower. The Cat-n-can combination will also load itself and dump itself in situations that would have a wheeled scraper struggling.

Just another 0.02. (God knows, I brought enough of 'em home from my last trip over your way.)

If you have any other queries, don't hesitate to ask. There is a LOT of help to be had on this BB.

You have a wonderful day. Best wishes. Deas Plant.

Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 11:16 AM
bobby1
Topic Author
Offline
Send a private message to bobby1
Posts: 288
Thank you received: 0
Reply to Deas Plant.:
Hi, Fastline.
Chapter One covers Kansas-Missouri. President is Fred Stitt - cell 816 289 2822 or e-mail: [email protected] He ought to be able to put you on to members in Kansas near you.

Happy hunting.

Glen's thumbnail calculations above will give you some idea of what you can expect the project to cost you and some of the options. A real good man with an elevator scraper could probably do most of it on his own. I know i could. How-wevver, when you start turning the inexperienced loose on building walls and banks, you start to run into safety issues like falling over the edge, etc.. Having a dozer or a blade around can help to reduce these risks.

Something of the same risks apply when using a crawler and drawn pan but the crawler is a bit more sure-footed than a wheeled scraper and doesn't travel as fast so you get into trouble a little slower. The Cat-n-can combination will also load itself and dump itself in situations that would have a wheeled scraper struggling.

Just another 0.02. (God knows, I brought enough of 'em home from my last trip over your way.)

If you have any other queries, don't hesitate to ask. There is a LOT of help to be had on this BB.
Considering the expense of moving distant equipment, I might have to try and use what is local to me. The Terex is 10 miles away on dirt roads. However, like I say, not really a fan from what I have seen.

One trick I was thinking and looks like a company is already doing it, is compressed air "lift" to reduce the loading forces once the bowl starts loading. I too notice that at about 50% load, they all seem to either need a push or need other assistance. We all know dirt ain't light so the overall design IMO is a bit flawed to use brute force to push all that dirt up in the bowl.

My family is with a large construction company but scoring big equipment for this duration and hours might be tough. BUT, maybe they would go for an even R&D swap of some of our engineering work to build an air system, in exchange for 100+ hours on the digger...👍

Well, at the very least, I am certainly thinking hard on an air system and with a few digits on the calculator anyway, it looks like we could save on some fuel and self load much easier. Of course, I don't exactly have a scraper to practice on, hint, hint...👋

To expand slightly on my mental design is to design a system that can create a compression wave frequency. Consider it like finding the frequency when a glass wants to hover off a table. Say 20-40hz.
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 12:08 PM
7upuller
Offline
Deceased
Send a private message to 7upuller
Posts: 3,737
Thank you received: 0
Reply to Deas Plant.:
Hi, Fastline.
Chapter One covers Kansas-Missouri. President is Fred Stitt - cell 816 289 2822 or e-mail: [email protected] He ought to be able to put you on to members in Kansas near you.

Happy hunting.

Glen's thumbnail calculations above will give you some idea of what you can expect the project to cost you and some of the options. A real good man with an elevator scraper could probably do most of it on his own. I know i could. How-wevver, when you start turning the inexperienced loose on building walls and banks, you start to run into safety issues like falling over the edge, etc.. Having a dozer or a blade around can help to reduce these risks.

Something of the same risks apply when using a crawler and drawn pan but the crawler is a bit more sure-footed than a wheeled scraper and doesn't travel as fast so you get into trouble a little slower. The Cat-n-can combination will also load itself and dump itself in situations that would have a wheeled scraper struggling.

Just another 0.02. (God knows, I brought enough of 'em home from my last trip over your way.)

If you have any other queries, don't hesitate to ask. There is a LOT of help to be had on this BB.
Hey Fastline,

What are the rough deminsions of the two ponds?
Are they all cut, or cut and fill?
I guess where I'm going with this is if the 225 can move all the cut to fill in 3-4 machine reaches, and don't need the trucks, than it will work with the excavator alone. Can you raise the top of dam grade up to keep more fill closer to the 225, and get away from the 800' haul?
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 12:08 PM
Claney
Offline
Send a private message to Claney
Posts: 172
Thank you received: 0
Reply to Deas Plant.:
Hi, Fastline.
Chapter One covers Kansas-Missouri. President is Fred Stitt - cell 816 289 2822 or e-mail: [email protected] He ought to be able to put you on to members in Kansas near you.

Happy hunting.

Glen's thumbnail calculations above will give you some idea of what you can expect the project to cost you and some of the options. A real good man with an elevator scraper could probably do most of it on his own. I know i could. How-wevver, when you start turning the inexperienced loose on building walls and banks, you start to run into safety issues like falling over the edge, etc.. Having a dozer or a blade around can help to reduce these risks.

Something of the same risks apply when using a crawler and drawn pan but the crawler is a bit more sure-footed than a wheeled scraper and doesn't travel as fast so you get into trouble a little slower. The Cat-n-can combination will also load itself and dump itself in situations that would have a wheeled scraper struggling.

Just another 0.02. (God knows, I brought enough of 'em home from my last trip over your way.)

If you have any other queries, don't hesitate to ask. There is a LOT of help to be had on this BB.
fastline ...what town in southcentral Kansas????

There is a dirt contractor in Belle Plaine that is also a member of the other club......ACME

We have a spring fling usually in May every year and are looking for projects to tear up/build. If you aren't too far from there??????

C u............Claney
Please log in or create an account to join the conversation.
Fri, Jan 27, 2012 12:17 PM
Showing 1 to 10 of 23 results
1
YouTube Video Placeholder

Follow Us on Social Media

Our channel highlights machines from the earliest Holt and Best track-type tractors, equipment from the start of Caterpillar in 1925, up to units built in the mid-1960s.

Upcoming Events

Chapter 2 The Link Club's AGM

Chapter Two

| Faulkner Farm, West Drove, Wisbech, Cambridgeshire, PE14 7DP, UK

HAMILTON PASTURAL MUSEUM

Chapter Nineteen

| Cnr Hiller Lane and Ballarat Road, Hamilton, Vic, 3300

RUSSELL SAYWELL WORKING DAY

Chapter Two

| Pitt Farm, Little Paxton, St Neots, Cambridgeshire, PE19 6HD, UK

10th Annual Best of the West

Chapter Fifteen

| Historic Santa Margarita Ranch, 20000 El Camino Real, Santa Margarita, CA 93453, USA
View Calendar
ACMOC

Antique Caterpillar
Machinery Owners Club

1115 Madison St NE # 1117
Salem, OR 97301

[email protected]

Terms & Privacy
Website developed by AdCo

Testimonials

"I became a member recently because the wealth of knowledge here is priceless." 
-Chris R

Join Today!